zBoneman.com -- Home Movie Reviews

Big Fish (2004)

Big Fish
So you want a job as a side show freak eh? What're you a man or a woman? And where's your nose? Tell y'what kid, throw in the giraffe and y'got a job.

Starring:

Albert Finney
Billy Crudup
Ewan McGregor
Jessica Lange
Alison Lohman

Released By:

Columbia Pictures

Released In:

2004

Rated:

PG

Reviewed By:

Adam Mast

Grade:

A-

Buy this item at Amazon.com
zBoneman on Rotten Tomatoes

Tim Burton is one of the most amazing visual storytellers of the last twenty years. While many were disappointed by his take on Planet of the Apes ( I liked the film, but I wouldn't call it one of his best), he remains a master of the craft. Big Fish is a stunning achievement and incorporates a dash of all the elements that make Tim Burton classics so stunning. In fact, I think this is his best work since Ed Wood.

In this endearing fantasy, Billy Crudup plays William Bloom, an earnest man who is trying to reconnect with Edward, his deathly ill father. Through the years, Edward has become a master storyteller, concocting wild tales of adventures with giants, going on the road with the circus, and befriending a creepy old witch. As a child, William always enjoyed the stories, but upon reaching adulthood, these tales and his father have become somewhat embarrassing, putting a strain on their relationship. As William reaches out to his dying father, we learn more about Edward's past through a series of fantastical flashbacks that feature Ewan McGregor as a young Finney.

Recently, I made the observation that Cold Mountain suffered a bit from it's fragmented plot structure. Big Fish is also fragmented but it works because it's a movie about tall tales. And while there is no doubt that this film tends to meander, it has enough whimsical energy and magic to mesmerize nearly every step of the way.

Tim Burton has infused his usual eccentric and offbeat sensibility into nearly every frame of Big Fish, but at it's core, this is a father and son story, and that keeps the movie grounded in reality. This picture is perfectly balanced.

While Big Fish is rife with visual splendor, there are also many terrific performances adding color to this vivid pallette. Billy Crudrup is outstanding as William. Even though this isn't a role of great depth, it rings true. Albert Finney is a seasoned pro and his ability to tell these stories is important, because we need to believe he can captivate those he's talking to. He pulls it off with flying colors. As I watched him, I couldn't help but think that I had met real men like him in my own life. Some of the emotional scenes where Crudup and Finney are reconnecting made the screen go a little blurry for me a few times. Jessica Lange is wonderful as Sandy and Alison Lohman perfectly compliments her as a younger version of Edward's wife. Big Fish is also populated by a perfect cast of bit parts played by noteworthy actors such as Danny DeVito, Steve Buscemi, Robert Guillaume, and Helena Bonham-Carter.

As I stated, Big Fish does have a real story at it's center. The whole movie really revolves around Edward and William, but this doesn't keep Burton from showcasing his visual talents. Save for Return of the King, this was probably my favorite movie to look at in 2003.

As it stands, Edward Scissorhands and Ed Wood tie for my favorite Tim Burton films. I can't pick between them. I can say that Big Fish, with it's magical tales (that, at times, reminded me of Forest Gump's adventures) and it's depiction of a father and son reconnecting, is my second favorite. And strangely enough, the three previously mentioned pictures, all feature central charactrers name Ed. Weird! (Could this be the final chapter of the Ed Trilogy?)

Big Fish is a film most of us can relate to because it's about a parent and child relationship. But it's also a movie that showcases the importance and power of stories. While we do learn, in a sense, whether or not some of the tales Edward is telling are true, we also come to realize that that really isn't the point. These stories helped this man get through life, and they also enriched and touched the lives of those whose ears they fell upon. That's what really matters. I loved Big Fish and it would have made my top ten of 2003 had I seen it in time.

:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::

Fishy

Fishy

I was wondering if this film officially came out in 2003 for Oscar considation or if it will be eligible for Awards in 2004 - usually movies that come out that early are forgotten about by the time the academy has to wring it out of their senile gray matter - I hope not, because I loved the film.

Adam

Adam

Fishy,

The movie officially came out in 2003 and was pretty much ignored by Oscar. At the very least, I thought it would be recognized for Art Direction and Cinematography. Ultimately, the only nomination it got was for Danny Elfman's amazing score (I thought it deserved to win). Big Fish will be released on DVD and video Tuesday, April 27thth.

Big Rip-off

Big Rip-off

I just read some of the commentary, regarding this film and was disheartened and actually pissed off that this film got completely ignored by the academy other than the score. This was a glorious film, that was one hell of a lot better than Cold Mountain and I guess came out in the year that would have made it eligible, unlike City of God. Whadderya gonna do?

Fish

Fish

I just saw this film on video for the first time, and I'm just incensed that it didn't win any awards. It was so much more moving and delightful than Cold Mountain. At least it didn't win much.

Barely a Keeper

Barely a Keeper

While any tim Burton film is certainly an event, I feel like the magic of Big Fish has been exaggerated. It suffered from what Mr. Mast commonly calls pacing problems - in fact there were sequences in the film that were borderline boring. It was more like a colllection of skits than a film. And saying so I realize that they were seperate memories, but I still say it was stagey and lacked the movie magic I was expecting. For Burton I'd say this is the one that got away.

Mitch Easterly

Mitch Easterly

I've read some of these comments regarding Big Fish, and for the most part I agree - the movie didn't quite succeed, but I don't think either of you touched on quite the right reason. The problem with the film, was that it didn't engage the audience emotionally until the very, very end. And yes, the point was well taken, that Bloom passed on what he thought was so important to his son, but by then it was just too late to work - which left only time for the most pat of endings. Plus where was all the Peter Gabriel and Yes music that they teased us with in the trailers?

Deep Sea Fishing

Deep Sea Fishing

I would agree that Big Fish is a flawed movie. One segment in particular (the one that features Danny DeVito) is too lengthy and a tad dull. I also feel that the love story in Big Fish lacks emotional depth, but the film hardly suffers from these flaws. Yes, the big father/son connection doesn't really happen until the end of the picture, but I don't even really think that their bond is the focal point of the movie. Big Fish is a movie about the power of stories, and on that level it more than succeeds.

I really bought into the magical, tall tale element of this beautiful movie. As far as Tim Burton's films, this certainly puts the director back on the right track. I don't think that Planet of the Apes is the horrible mess that many make it out to be, but it is my least favorite of his efforts. Big Fish is far superior. At the very least, it's a visual feast. And I'll take the visual splendor of a Burton film over that of a Roland Emmerich or Stephen Summers movie any day of the week.

Michael Mitchell

Michael Mitchell

I would just like to say first off that I am not and never have been a Tim Burton fan. I am intriged and hugely intrested in how a film is approached by the director and usually find this the most fascinating thing about the movie. I have watched previous films by Tim Burton and been completely unimpressed and somewhat freaked out by his directing. I went to see Big Fish, however, because I am a fan of Ewan McGregor. When I left the cinema I was naturally impressed by McGregor's performance which is usually to a very good standard but I was even more takenaback at how maticulous and amazingly accurate Burton had been in directing this movie.

I can say straight off that this has to be one of my favourite films of all time. I have never been more moved and awed by a film before. Watching Big Fish was like an amazing dream that you can finally remember and feel a part of. The camera angle and the lense colour for this film was perfect. Burton has excelled in this movie and I have to say I am definitely going to see his future work because I believe he has finally found himself as a director.

Not only was the film a directing masterpiece the story was full of sentiment, joy, love and hope. The busy and awesome storyline really drew me in as I watched. The script was also very well written - believable and still heart-wrenchingly moving. The acting was top class, enthusiastic and energetic.

All I can say is, if you are unsure of whether to see this film or not read this review again and make sure you do. Because if you don't, you may be missing the best film you have ever seen.

Snick At Nite

Snick At Nite

Big Fish is a terribly over-rated film and never was this point made more clear than when I saw Lemony Snicket. Snicket is a far superior film, granted each film is playing opposite sides of the same fence emotionally, The acting and strory and visuals were stronger in Snicket. I never thought I'd think that about a Burton Film

SD

SD

In the telling of his fathers life it was impossible to separate fact from fiction, the man from the myth the best that Will Bloom can do is tell it how it was told to him. For the story and life of Edward Bloom is larger than life and almost impossible to separate the tales from what truly happened, as he has always been a teller of tall-tales about his oversized life as a young man. When wanderlust struck Edward it led him on an unlikely journey from a small-town of Ashton Alabama, around the world, and back again. His mythic exploits dart from the delightful to the delirious as he weaves epic tales about giants, a witch and conjoined-twin lounge singers. With his larger-than-life stories, Bloom charms almost everyone he encounters except for his estranged son Will. For when Will was a boy he loved the stories of his father's life but now that he has grown older and heard their recounting so many times he has grown weary of them and resentful that his father never told him the truth. But when his father grows ill his mother Sandra tries to reunite them, and now Will must learn how to separate fact from fiction as he comes to terms with his father's great feats and great failings as he attempts to reconcile with not only his father but also his past as he tries to unfold the story of his fathers life for future generations of Bloom's. But it may be too little to late as both is father and Will may have grown too far apart by the wedge the stories set between them.

What an absolutely fascinating tale of some incredible and amazing stories that just thrills and amazes you. But it's more than just that as the movie also manages to enthrall you with some great drama as Edward and Will try and reconcile their differences before Edward dies. The movie has a little bit of everything from fanciful characters, to amazing feats, to great drama and even a liberal amount of comedy. Tim Burton clearly has an amazing imagination and he also has an incredible talent of bringing it to the screen where he can share it with the whole world. The movie is almost borderline fantasy while at the same time being bound so wonderfully to reality with the drama of father and son at odds end over the stories of one man's life. Sure, the ending might be a little anti-climatic as I would have preferred to leave all the fanciful tales to the imagination of the audience but its Hollywood after all and such an unclean ending is not normally allowed nor accepted. Still the movie is an amazing piece of work that combines the wonders of Tim Burton with the great acting skills of Ewan McGregor, Albert Finney and Jessica Lange. It is very easy to believe Ewan as the younger version of Albert as they both do splendid jobs of capturing you and enthralling you in the movie that is itself larger than life.

jimmy chee

jimmy chee

When I watched Lemmony Snicket it made me think of Big Fish, mainly how much more entertaining Jim Carrey is than Ewan McGregor.

Bob

Bob

Big fish is much much better than Lemony Snicket - you're on crack dude

Add your own comment here and see it posted immediately!
Name: e-Mail:
Comment:
Spam Prevention Check:
Please enter the following code in the box below.
Security Image