zBoneman.com -- Home

Movie Reviews

American Splendor (2003)

American Splendor
"These slacks don't make me look dumpy--what are you talking about?"

Starring:

Paul Giamatti

Released By:

HBO Video

Released In:

2003

Rated:

R

Reviewed By:

Adam Mast

Grade:

A-

Buy this item at Amazon.com
zBoneman on Rotten Tomatoes

Primarily known for American Slendor, an insightful comic book that he collaborated on with Robert Crumb, Harvey Pekar was an interesting fellow who'd pass his time reading, writing and listening to jazz. Before meeting Crumb, he was a lonely burnout with a bored life, but with American Splendor becoming more and more popular, and the addition of a girlfriend, Pekar would soon become a burnout in love.

American Splendor is a fantastically entertaining film in the tradition of Ghost World.

Paul Giamatti gets more interesting with each performance, and he's a perfect fit for Pekar's eccentricities.

Film makers Shari Springer Berman and Robert Pulcini have crafted a funny and sometimes tender look at love and creativity. From their innovative opening comic book credits sequence to the stylized inner cutting of actual Pekar interview footage, American Splendor is a film that works on many levels.

Quite frankly, I never would have believed that Pekar was as odd as he's portrayed in the film, but we are given interview sessions of the actual man that prove he was that odd.

From the creation of American Splendor to several guest spots on David Letterman, Pekar was an interesting guy with an interesting life. American Splendor gives us a glimpse into that life, and I loved every second of it.

:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::

Pekarhead

Pekarhead

American Splendor is cool thing for two different reasons. Number one it offered Harvey Pekar the tribute that he deserves and it also provided Paul Giamatti a wonderful opportunity to shine in a role that he was born to play. I've liked Giamatti in a number of films from Private Parts and hell, he even made Duets watchable, and I'm glad to see he got some recognition for this role it's a fantastic little film, that everyone should check out.

Splendid

Splendid

I've become obsessed with this movie. True I'm a fan of both Pekar and Crumb, but there's something about this glimpse into the mind of one of my heroes is so compelling that I've literally watched this film well over 50 times and there just no seems to be an end in sight. Is this normal or should I seek help - seriously!

Bill Jannsen

Gotcha

Gotcha

I hope one day Paul Giamatti is recognized for his talent. I know he recieved accolades for this performance, but the truth is he elevates anything he's in. From Private Parts to Duets - his screen time always improves the film.

WTFDYC

WTFDYC

American Splendor is spledid and all and I've always been a fan of Giamatti so it's a sure fire thumbs up. Given the subject matter, I guess the filmmakers did not want to make Crumb Redux, which is too bad, because the documentary segments of the film were the most interesting, even considering the quality of Paul Giamatti and Hope Davis's performances (I guess it was a Hope Davis week for me; man, did she really look like Joyce). The real Harvey Pekar is just such a compelling character, that my level of interest lagged whenever the docudrama were on screen (though I did enjoy Pekar's voice over commentary during these scenes). The film's mixture of documentary, docudrama, animation, and clips is a postmodern stew that serves to illustrate a central question that Harvey asks Joyce (I'll have to paraphrase, it was over a week ago): "Am I a character who writes comic books, or a character in a comic book?" Allyn is right though, the film does kind of peter out in the humor department, and the ending is fairly conventional,

Add your own comment here and see it posted immediately!
Name: e-Mail:
Comment:
Spam Prevention Check:
Please enter the following code in the box below.
Security Image