zBoneman.com -- Home Movie Reviews

Assault On Precinct 13 (2005)

Assault On Precinct 13
"Look at this? This is bullshit! I want this place barred-up and locked-down Before Sunrise - make that Before Sunset!"

Starring:

Ethan Hawke
Laurence Fishburne
Maria Bello
Gabriel Byrne

Released By:

Rogue Pictures

Released In:

2005

Rated:

R

Reviewed By:

Adam Mast

Grade:

C+

Buy this item at Amazon.com
zBoneman on Rotten Tomatoes

Assault on Precinct 13 is a retelling of John Carpenter's stylized actioneer from 1976. Even though that picture wasn't exactly regarded as a classic, it was Carpenter's follow-up to the little seen Dark Star, and sort of put his name on the map (he would do the infamous Halloween shortly after). I've always had a fondness for that movie (as I do for most of Carpenter's efforts). As a siege picture, Assault on Precinct 13 had all the right ingredients, most notably tension and an undeniable sense of claustrophobia.

This version has similar such attributes along with an updated twist - this time, the villains are a pack of murderous, crooked cops as opposed to your standard street hoods. Recalling the classic western, Assault on Precinct 13 sets up a simplistic premise and plays out a little like Howard Hawks' Rio Bravo, albeit not as memorable.

In this violent, action flick, Ethan Hawke is burned-out police officer Jake Roenick. Along with a couple of fellow officers and a few criminals they're holding in a cell at a soon-to-be-closed Precinct 13, this reluctant team is forced to work together so that they might fend off an army of masked men who have taken the condemned precinct, under siege. Compounding the situation is the fact that it's New Year's Eve, there's a horrendous blizzard and well, they're in Detroit,. The attackers' objective? To capture prisoner Bishop (played by Laurence Fishburne), a crime lord with ties in the highest of places.

Assault on Precinct 13 is fast-paced and never pretends to be high art. It's all pretty straight forward action fare and the movie is perfectly comfortable in it's own skin. In other words, be prepared to be assaulted with an onslaught of bullets and bloodshed. This isn't a character driven movie, although Ethan Hawke does manage to create a fully textured role. At times, I almost felt as if his Jake belonged in a different movie.

Hawke is very good here, and his first scene is particularly noteworthy, even if it did remind me of the hyper kinetic opening frames of Joe Carnahan's Narc. Fishburne pretty much just duplicates his Morpheus role from The Matrix. He has a quietness about him, but we're always completely aware that he can go ballistic if need be-and he does. Maria Bello has a few nice moments as a psychiatrist with obsessive-compulsive disorder. Brian Dennehy, playing a sort of variation of his role in First Blood, is fun as a grizzled, old time police officer. Gabriel Byrne is on cruise control as a cop with an agenda, while Drea de Matteo is positively laughable as a nymphomaniac secretary (which is too bad given her rich portrayal on The Sopranos).

The criminals that join forces with Jake are completely stock. John Leguizamo is particularly annoying as a spastic drug addict. He's the token comic relief, and his routine wears thin quickly. I suppose there's something to be said for his energy though.

This Assault on Precinct 13 was directed by John Francois-Richet, and he does do a good job setting the mood. The introduction to Jake is intense, and as the picture progresses, we do feel isolated with the characters trapped in the precinct. The pouring snow heightens the tension. I also thought this picture had a lot of balls. Several characters die rather unexpectedly, but the proceedings would have been far more effective had we known some of these people a little bit more.

The action is standard. And in fact, one scene in particular appears to be a direct lift from a John McClane terrorist offing in Die Hard 2. Often, Richet puts us too close to the action so that it's hard to see what's going on. Still, and I was never really bored.

Assault on Precinct 13 has it's moments and I appreciate that it is what it is and never really takes itself seriously. That makes the ridiculous dialogue and situations tolerable. Richet is no John Carpenter, but his film does move at a quick pace . At the very least, I found it more entertaining than the recent Flight of the Phoenix and that silly National Treasure movie.

:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::

Captain Crap

Captain Crap

Attack on Precinct 13 would have been better left in the memroy of John Carpenter fanatics. While the original did offer some fairly striking images - it was far from a classic and this new retread brings nothing new to the party. Waste of tanlent.

liujie

liujie

Underated flick - I didn't see to many cirtics flipping over it, but I thought it was quite suspensefull and a worthy remake of the original

shinji

shinji

Way to hokey and over the top - too much rah rah and predictable crap, People shooting at each other for two hours - I can get that on CNN

Sir Dizzy

Sir Dizzy

With only a few hours left in the calendar year, Precinct 13, one of Detroit's oldest precinct houses, is closing. Amid heavy snowfall and unsafe road conditions, only a few lawmen remain on duty for New Year's Eve. They are headed by Sergeant Jake Roenick (Ethan Hawke), a good cop wrestling with bad memories of a fatal undercover op from the previous spring. Early on December 31st, formidable crime lord Marion Bishop (Laurence Fishburne) is cornered by an undercover cop. Their ensuing struggle leaves the cop dead, but Bishop captured by the Organized Crime and Racketeering squad run by Marcus Duval (Gabriel Byrne). Bishop is loaded on a bus with other criminals, but the battering snowstorm stops the bus well short of its high security destination. They prisoners are instead stranded at remote and rundown Precinct 13 where they're temporarily incarcerated. When two masked gunmen break in and attack the guards from the bus, everyone inside Precinct 13 realizes that more will come to extract Bishop. With minimal weaponry and maximum courage, they will not go gently into the night, and the thin lines between good and bad bleed together.

There are great movies, then there are good movies, then there are just Ok movies, sadly this movie falls into that last category. The movie was not terrible by any means but neither was it great. The movie was pure popcorn, which is sad because the movie had more potential than that shown by the original. Remakes to me just seem like movies thrown out really quick to garner a fast book when studios run out of ideas. Rarely are they as good as the originals and even more rarely is there a need to remake them. Assault on Precinct has its moments and is fairly entertaining, filled with action and gunfire but that is all there is too the movie. This is the kind of movie you see for a matinee, fairly enjoy yourself and then quickly forget it as the movie leaves no mark whatsoever as its no imaginative or anything new.

Laurence Fishburne is getting old and it's starting to show. He does a good job as the badass mobster but he never really had that much range as actor and is just been made famous by his roles in the Matrix. Ethan Hawke is the one who steals the show, his character is probably the only three dimensional character on the screen as Fishburne is so one dimensional its not even funny. Everyone likes a badass villain and Fishburne does ok, but nowhere near the king of that role Samuel L Jackson. Its Hawke's performance that saves the movie and gives it what little depth the movie has. I was absolutely surprised by one moment where they escaped the clichés and managed to something I wasn't expecting and that almost made the movie worth it.

Add your own comment here and see it posted immediately!
Name: e-Mail:
Comment:
Spam Prevention Check:
Please enter the following code in the box below.
Security Image