zBoneman.com -- Home Movie Reviews

Eternal Sunshine of The Spotless Mind (2004)

Eternal Sunshine of The Spotless Mind
While fooling around on the set, Jim decided to erase Pet Detective 2, long story short he's now living in Utah under a witness protection program.

Starring:

Jim Carrey
Kate Winslet
Kirsten Dunst
Elijah Wood
Mark Ruffalo
Tom Wilkenson

Released By:

Focus Features

Released In:

2004

Rated:

R

Reviewed By:

Adam Mast

Grade:

A

Buy this item at Amazon.com
zBoneman on Rotten Tomatoes

Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind the Boneman got to see before me. Yes while I was taking in a screening of the sporadically entertaining yet shallowly written Dawn of the Dead, my good friend the Boneman was experiencing what will surely be one of the best films of the year, and quite possibly, the decade. Both of our screenings ended around the same time, and upon talking to the Boneman in the lobby, it was clear that he was blown away by the film because he was...speechless. After a few moments of exhilirating silence, he went on to explain to me that this is quite possibly the best film of the century--granted it is only 2004 so there's still a long way to go. You can read his shining review among the responses below.

A couple of weeks ago, I raved about screenwriters David Mamet, Quentin Tarantino and Steven Zaillian. Clearly, Charlie Kaufman deserves a spot on this list (a list that probably would have also included his brother Donald had he not passed away all too soon). Kaufman began writing for television (notable credits include Get a Life and The Drew Carey Show). He then went on to write Human Nature, but it wasn't until Being John Malkovich that he really started to garner attention. Shortly thereafter, Mr. Kaufman would dazzle the industry and film goers everywhere with his innovative screenplays for Adaptation and Confessions of a Dangerous Mind. True, much of his work is not everyone's cup of tea. The previously mentioned works are offbeat to say the least, but if your up to the challenge, the're definitely worth a look.

Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind emerges as the writer's best work because (unlike Being John Malkovich and Adaptation which took drastic direction changes in their final acts), tonally speaking, it's the most consistent. But more importantly, it's a film that most of us can really identify with because it's about that unpredictable thing called love.

I don't want to get to much into the plot because to do so would ruin all the wonderful, unexpected surprises of this richly textured, innovative piece of art. Not to mention that I would take the rather large risk of confusing the hell out of all you readers out there.

In reality, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind is far more simplistic than recent reviews and the brilliant trailers suggest. There certainly is a kind of complexity to it all, but ultimately, the movie is easy to digest.

Jim Carrey is the intellectual but socially awkward Joel Barish, a man who is, without warning, bitten by the love bug when he meets the lovably eccentric and carefree Clementine Kruczyaski (played wonderfully by Kate Winslet). The two immediately fall for one another, but as is the case in many relationships, things slowly begin to sour. In an attempt to forget about Joel and move on with her troubled life, Clementine seeks out a rather unorthodox method to rid herself of the heartache. Unable to cope with the unbearable pain himself, Joel seeks the same method, only things don't quite turn out the way he had anticipated.

Jim Carrey has proven himself to be a surprisingly effective dramatic actor, and I would call this performance a milestone in his career. He's very quiet and his moments of internal suffering are painfully real. This is a side of Carrey we haven't seen before, and I applaud his understated work here. Winslet is equally effective as a woman who is easily annoyed and seeks attention in ways that many might consider unhealthy. Her Clementine has an energy and spirit that, along with a brilliant Carrey, bring this zany, surreal, heartbreaking movie to life. And while these two are the focal point of the movie, there are other relationships to be found in the form of outstanding supporting players Mark Ruffalo, Kirsten Dunst, Tom Wilkinson and Elijah Wood.

Kaufman's screenplay is incredibly observant and he appears to have a grasp on all of the components--big and small--that make relationships work and fall apart. Director Michael Gondry (who also directed Kaufman's Human Nature) is a true craftsman. His stylistic techniques are flawless. Much of Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind unfolds like a series of memories. In other words, there is a certain fragmented style here, but everything always makes sense. And I have to say, I was blown away by the numerous transition shots that take us from one memory to the next. But while visually stunning, this picture is always a character study first and foremost.

And check out the interesting use of music. Songwriter Jon Brion (he's worked with the likes of Aimee Mann) has fashioned an odd, unique, but very appropriate score, and even Beck gets in on the action with a perfectly fitting tune called "Everybody's Gotta Learn Sometimes." The soundtrack also includes outstanding songs from The Willowz and The Polyphonic Spree.

Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind is sweet, honest, heartbreaking and challenging. It's also very unpredictable. I must confess, I had no idea where the movie was headed, but when the end arrived, it was perfectly clear that these two souls had learned from their mistakes but not quite in the way they (or we) were expecting.

Usually, when a film is hyped up to me by someone I respect (or otherwise), I'm set up for a letdown. The Boneman is someone I respect, and as much as he built this picture up, I was still blown away by it. Chances are, you will be too.

This is the sort of profound piece of film making that will be studied and viewed over and over. I've already seen it twice and can't wait to see it again. The year is early, but add Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind to that short list thus far, of movies that will be among the best of 2004

:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::

The Boneman

The Boneman

Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind is a Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius. Charlie Kaufman! We've already been witness to his quirky ability to explore the human heart and mind - but this represents a breath-taking leap forward. What Star Wars was to outer-space and what Lord of the Rings is to Fantasy, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind is to "Reality." By painting with a most surreal brush, a picture that, at first and up close, is dizzying and daunting, Kaufman slowly brings you far enough away so that you slowly gain some perspective, and by the time the paint has dried, you?re high enough to grasp the grand design. And then it becomes crystal clear what Kaufman has done. He?s lain before us, like an aerial map of a carnival, precisely what love is and exactly how it works.

By using tools that others have used, Jim Carrey, Kate Winslet, a computer, a camera, a special effect or two, he?s managed to flesh-out the most intangible and mercurial concept of all. With an ingenious eye trained on nothing but the truth, Charlie has cornered love to a point where it cannot escape our perception. There it is, with a definable shape - a thing with warts and hair and pulsing boundaries. It morphs, mind you, between an ?angel of light? and a monstrous freak - but it?s on display at your local multiplex should you wish to get a closer look.

Films like this rarely, if ever, get made these days. I?m sure to raise the hackle of many a purist, but this is the sort of art that Bergman and Fellini and Woody Allen labored with. By borrowing some of the wild imagery and symbolism from these classic pioneers and the wit and wordplay of Woody, the script is so brilliant in it?s (all too real) dialogue that you scarcely notice what impeccable performances are being offered by the entire cast--which also includes Mark Ruffalo and David Cross (who could be identical brothers) Kirsten Dunst, Tom Wilkinson and of course Elijah Wood.

The thing about this movie that you should understand above all, is that it?s really simple and easy to follow if you don?t over-think it. What at first appears to be a twisted mind-trip turns out to be a fairly straight forward story. A story of two fugitives, who quite ironically find themselves racing through a maze of synapses and gray matter desperately trying to cling to one memory. The memory that ?love is the thing,? and to conceal it from view in order that it not be erased. As the story unfolds we as witnesses are rapt, because Charlie, the author of this tale and the unquestionable star of this film, has achieved immortality. As we sit in our comfortable red velvet chairs, scarcely touching the Red Vines and the Soda in it?s Soda-Hole - Kaufman reads to us, chapter and verse, from the very book of love. I left the theater stunned and I don?t believe there will be a finer film made for a long time.

Bill Dobbins

Bill Dobbins

Just wanted to see if this thing really works and say I couldn't agree more with your opinion of Eternal Sunshine. I will be sorely disappointed if Jim Carrey isn't considered come Oscar time, and to be honest, I've never been all that big of a fan. I also wanted to mention that you were right about Intermission, I think between the two you've got the best films of the year. The Passion was great, but if you're a writer you have to admire the other films for their character and plot structure. It's about time you got one of these on your site by the way, I thought maybe you guys were from outter space, cool site - a fan.

Eternal Sunshine Through

Eternal Sunshine Through

If Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind isn't nominated for the best film of the year I will personally boycott cinema for the rest of my life. By far the most astonishing film experience of the year, and though I agree the Passion should contest it, the script in ET is superior to anything written for years.

Jake

Jake

I was disappointed that the film was overlooked as badly as it was at the Golden Globes. I love Sideways but Kaufman should have won for his script. It's true that a lot of films have come along of late and stolen it's thunder, but in general these are all pretty standard movies, whereas Eternal Sunshine was strikingly original and pushed the envelope of the medium and for that it should be recognized. Looking forward to Mr. Masts list.

Sunshine

Sunshine

No matter what happens come award time,. people know that Eternal Sunshine is the most imaginative and envelope pushing film made in years. Ten years from now no one is going to be talking about Million Dollar Baby or the Aviator, the the Sunshine will still shine as brightly, Just thought that needed to be said,

Brandon

Brandon

This is an absolutely amazing movie. I'd would write my thoughts on it here, but I'm afraid the Boneman wrote it up there too eloquently himself.

At the end of 2004, this film had cemented itself in my favourites of the year. Sideways, Closer, Million Dollar Baby, and the other Oscar contenders were all great films (some of which are amongst my all time favourites) and at the time I couldn't really disagree with their numerous nominations. In fact, I bought all three of those films shortly after their release on DvD. As time as worn on however, Eternal Sunshine has taken a place well above the others mentioned here.

The reason I have singled out those four films is that they all have a timeless quality to them. While other films are great works of cinema in their own right (Ray, the Aviator) it's these fictional tales that tell us a real, genuine story of human emotion and who we are. Million Dollar Baby illustrates the importance of the bonds we share with other people and what we'll do to make them happy. Sideways underlines the importance of relationships and how we need them in our lives to be truly content, whether we want to or not. Closer offers a great examination of love as it pertains to our relationships with other people, and maybe why we act the way we do with these emotions. Really though, Sunshine steals the spotlight in the way that it brilliantly dissects and maps out love with surgical accuracy. It is a film that while at first glance is very complicated, really makes an incredibly complicated subject far easier to understand. It's something that I think everyone should see because I really do think that at least in the smallest way it could change your life and how you see things. For a film to do that puts it well above the title of "Oscar Winner", but rather as one of the better works of art of our time.

Add your own comment here and see it posted immediately!
Name: e-Mail:
Comment:
Spam Prevention Check:
Please enter the following code in the box below.
Security Image