zBoneman.com -- Home

Movie Reviews

Pride and Prejudice (2005)

Pride and Prejudice
The film's creators were forced to cut Elizabeth's failed suicide attempt, in order to avoid the dreaded, box office killing (PG-13) rating.

Starring:

Keira Knightly
Matthew MacFayden
Brenda Blethyn
Judi Dench
Donald Sutherland

Released By:

Focus Features

Released In:

2005

Rated:

PG

Reviewed By:

The Boneman

Grade:

B+

Buy this item at Amazon.com
zBoneman on Rotten Tomatoes

Miraculously, for the entirety of my 45 years here on earth, I have somehow managed to avoid seeing so much as a channel-surfing snippet of Jane Austen's beloved Pride and Prejudice. No easy task as it has seen countless filmed incarnations (this one making the third in the past 2 years). Being a fan of Colin Firth's take on a different Darcy in Bridget Jones' D' Iary, I've been the most tempted to break my impressive streak of P & P abstinence, by renting his famous Darcy doings, but the thought of 5 hours of stuffy BBC-ified anything was enough to secure my record. And now it is only out of a sense of duty to this website, and the fact that even my most macho friends have returned from it with favorable reports, that I have, at long last, experienced the fanciful follies of the Bennett family and stand ready to disabuse anyone with similar predispositions (okay Prejudices).

Pride and Prejudice, faithfully rendered (or so I've read) by first time director Joe Wright, is a fine bit of smart and often poignant entertainment, centered around a family with upper-class aspirations, but limited means. The story takes place at a time in British history when social stratification was the order of the day - an unwritten law that many would have preferred to see enforceable. Their five daughters (two, Jane and Elizabeth, eligible by age for marriage) stand as the best shot the family has of improving their societal lot, and this is pretty much the only thing that their mother (Brenda Blethyn) ever thinks about. Mrs. Bennett is far from being a woman of refinement and grace - a bit daft and dotty around the edges - and though a devoted wife, is completely obsessed by the prospect of obtaining a ticket into upper-class society visa-vie a strategic marriage or two. In the profound words of David Byrne - same as it ever was.

When Mr. Bingley - a handsome, moneyed and aristocratic bachelor (Simon Woods) moves into their village - it sets the Bennett household into something of a state - particularly as Mr. Bingley is often seen in the company of a mysterious and handsome gentleman freind. The lot of them first meet at local social function, where Bingley takes a fast fancy for Jane, unfortunately his enigmatic and ostensibly snobbish friend Mr. Darcy (Matthew MacFayden) gets off to a miserable start with Elizabeth. Of course anyone who's seen at least five movies in their life, instantly knows where matters such as this are headed.

Up until now, I've written Keira Knightly off as the new model Winona Rider, and other than Pirates of the Caribbean and Love Actually, actually I was pretty much unfamiliar with her work - though naturally I've read a good deal about her. At this point, I should confess that I'm ready to head up a local chapter or her fan club. She literally tears the hinges off of this sucker and with Austen's wry witticisms flowing naturally from her exquisite mouth, you'll want to join my little club yourself.

As for the rest of the cast, Donald Sutherland is strong as the beleaguered and bemused patriarch of the Bennett family and Judi Dench is deliciously despicable as Lady Catherine - a condescending, yet officious woman of local nobility. Dench is so good at inspiring your misanthropy that you'd literally like to see her eaten alive by wild sheep. Quite a testament to her thespian prowess. Also impressive is MacFayden's Darcy. For his part he gambles that he can win you over when his character turns in the final act, after playing the "know your place-card" and remaining unlikably aloof throughout most of the film. He manages this with charming aplomb, due mostly to the fact that we know all along that his abrasiveness is just a disguise to hide his attraction to Elizabeth - in spite of his low opinion of her family. Besides, playing hard to get almost never fails - same as it ever was. As far as I know, this is the only thing I've seen him in, and he manages to be quite winning, despite his unconventional, almost lopsided, Bohemian look.

There are a number of subplots, one involving a younger Bennett sister (Jena Malone) who becomes entangled with the wrong sort of fellow. An unfortunate turn of circumstance that requires a clever bit of chicanery on the part of her loved ones to extricate her from. And naturally there are a lot of hearts battered, bruised and broken along side the matrimonial trail.

As a matter of course, the film is going to stand or fall on the strength of how effectively the love story is rendered. I must admit that I was quite taken with it, even though such love-hate relationships have become awfully cliché since Austen wrote her story nearly 200 years ago. Still, this is a tale told with such wit and wisdom that when, at long last, it turns physical, the passion literally radiates from the two of them in palpable waves. In the end, Elizabeth relies less on her heart-stopping beauty, and more on her honesty and solid character to lure Darcy's true feelings out of hiding and by the final act it becomes clear that he is likewise a man of great loyalty and character. Once Elizabeth realizes these things, and sees beyond her own pride, she lights up in a way that cannot be directed and you won't soon forget. Oftimes you'll hear a woman described as being luminous - indeed the light that eminates from within young Miss Knightly may very well cause permanent retina damage.

Along with picture perfect period detail and cinematography that is beyond sumptuous, Pride and Prejudice hits so many of the right notes that it literally sings. It will go down in history as one of those rare creations: a quintessential chick flick that men cannot resist. As far as I'm concerned it will remain a fluke, just one of those guilty pleasures and nothing more. For crying out loud.

:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::

Penny Beckstead

Penny Beckstead

It's about time you guys reveiwed Pride and Prej, I was afraid you didn't like it and that would have brought you down in my mind. It's really cool to see this move doing so good with the critics and making money because I just love it so much. I have done my part cuz I've seen it 3 times. Hey i'm not proud.

Brady Ferguson

Brady Ferguson

You're bloody well right - I've seen it twice with both of the women I've been seeing and each time I saw a little bit of a different film, as I tend to experience movies alomst vicariously through whomever I'm with. In any case I loved it both times and of course so did the ladies.

Drew Roundy

Drew Roundy

I have a little confession to make myself. I went to Pride and Prejuduce with my two sisters. And I really felt like wearing some sort of disguise because I was pretty embarassed to be going to see it. After it was over though I had no such feelings and left the theater proudly with a sister on either arm and a couple of damp tissues in my pocket. Probably the best chick flick I've seen since the Notebook.

Astrid Jones

Astrid Jones

To be honest, I think you're a little bit off by calling Pride and prejudice a chick flick. It's indeed a classic romance, but I've noticed that a lot of guys seem to be pretty keen on this one as well. In fact I got a call from a boyfriend that I'd just broken it off with not more than 3 months ago and he said he'd gone to see it with his mates and that he'd had to bat away the tears, because it reminded him of our situation. Actually I'm well rid of the bleeder and he'd have to be a rich aristocrat who looked like Matthew MacFayden for me to consider hauling him back aboard that's for bloody sure.

Marte Jamison

Marte Jamison

Since you don't have any chat board in your humor section I just wanted to congratulate you for that piece on Christmas, I laughed out loud and Emailed it to my Mother. It's funny because I've been on this site a number of times and that's the first time I ever clicked over there - I've since read several and think you're about as funny as anyone I've ever read.

Porgy ass

Porgy ass

Curious - Pride and Prej seems to be getting almost universally strong reviews, but as yet I haven't heard any sort of Oscar buzz - do you think that's out of the question?

James Davis

James Davis

Like yourself I went to P and P (with my girlfriend) fully prepared to spend the next two hours rolling my eyes at everything on the screen, but wound up coming away from the film with a newfound appreciation for Jane Austen, and in fact I'd put this movie in the top ten films I've seen this year. Go figure.

Add your own comment here and see it posted immediately!
Name: e-Mail:
Comment:
Spam Prevention Check:
Please enter the following code in the box below.
Security Image