Those expecting Riding in Cars With Boys to be the light, cheery entertainment the trailer suggests, are going to be sorely disappointed. Although this picture does have it's funny moments, it is a surprisingly joyless movie.
Based on the book, this film spans several years in the life of Beverly (Drew Barrymore). As the film starts off, we are introduced to Beverly as a young girl. She is full of life and wit, and is always at odds with her father (James Woods). Things become worse when Bev enters her teenage years and a couple of bad decisions change her life forever. This leads into a tough adulthood as Beverly must deal with the mistakes of her past to create a better future.
Director Penny Marshall does deserve credit for avoiding the sentimental and manipulative pitfalls that you might think this picture will take. Still, Riding in Cars With Boys is very dreary and doesn't really allow the audience to sympathize with anyone. In this regard, I was reminded of Rob Reiner's Story of Us.
Barrymore doesn't quite have the range needed to fully color the canvas of Beverly's life. Although she's a beauty to behold and a likable screen force (the scene in which she does a cute little dance for her son is priceless), much of her performance seems stilted, particularly in the moments when she's playing a teenager.
Bringing the picture to life are the supporting performances. Steve Zahn (who was also terrific in the recent Joy Ride) is spectacular as Barrymore's drug-addicted husband. Although his character is slightly underwritten, he takes the part to new heights with his compassion and sincerity. In fact, the film's two best scenes involve his character. I also enjoyed Brittany Murphy (Don't Say A Word, Clueless) as Barrymore's spunky best friend. And let's not forget the always dependable James Woods. This is an extremely small role, but his presence as Barrymore's hardened father is essential to the way we look a Beverly's actions throughout the film.
Penny Marshall has made two great movies (Awakenings and Big) and one good one (A League of Their Own). Outside of those pictures, she's made fairly forgettable flicks like Preacher's Wife, Jumpin Jack Flash, and Renaissance Man. Riding in Cars With Boys isn't nearly as good as Marshall's best, but I wouldn't put it at the bottom of her resume either.
:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::