zBoneman.com -- Home

Movie Reviews

Saints and Soldiers (2004)

Saints and Soldiers
"There's this aetheist in our company who smokes, drinks, cusses like the devil, calls all women whores and, oh yea - he saved my life. Great guy."

Starring:

Corbin Allred
Kirby Heyborn
Larry Bagby

Released By:

Excel

Released In:

2004

Rated:

PG-13

Reviewed By:

Adam Mast

Grade:

B

zBoneman on Rotten Tomatoes

Saints and Soldiers is a surprisingly effective war film. I say surprising because it was shot on a very low budget, and yet the films creators have fashioned a great-looking, impressively written and executed film that manages to get across a strong message.

Taking place shortly before the infamous Battle of the Bulge, Saints and Soldiers tells the story of a group of American GI's stranded behind enemy lines during a mission to rescue a British pilot in possession of vital information for the Allied forces. As the film progresses these soldiers learn a great deal about one another. They come from a wide variety of ethnic and geographical backgrounds and, despite their various differences, a strong bond develops between the men. One of them, for example happens to be Mormon, and in the early going the others don't quite know what to make of him, but soon, they realize that - surprise - he's just a person much like the rest of them.

Saints and Soldiers was made by L.D.S. film makers, but it's aimed at a much broader audience than the recent onslaught of Mormon themed films (i.e. Home Teachers, The R.M. and Pride and Prejudice). Not that I'm anti-L.D.S. mind you. Far from it. I'm married to a member of the church and she is quite possibly the best thing that ever happened to me (no, this is not an attempt at kissing up - I'm being sincere). It's just that far too often, L.D.S. films are weakened by their overt attept to beat the audience over the head with the gospel. A trap that Saints and Soldiers deftly avoids. The religious overtones in this film are very subtle and this is both welcome and refreshing.

Corbin Allred's Nathan "Deacon" Greer is a soft-spoken soldier, and while his faith does become pivitol to the story, it's used in an honest fashion and doesn't necessarily become the emphasis of the film. In fact, save for one heavy-handed moment (one that involves an attempted shooting) I found the entire scenario surprisingly restrained.

As for the rest of the picture, it is extremely efficient. Even though this film was shot on a boot-string budget, the attention paid to period detail is picture perfect. The battle sequences are well staged, the costume design is outstanding, the locations are extremely realistic and the cinematography is extremely impressive. Much of it is hand held, but this benefits the picture and lends a kind of intimacy to the foxhole melee.

There is war carnage to be found in Saints and Soldiers, but this isn't a bloody affair. It is a very accessible film, and while the lack of in-your-face violence may seem unrealistic to some, I wasn't bothered because this particular movie has something else to say.

The performances here are terrific, and each soldier is well drawn. The standouts are a quietly effective Allred, whose performance has a subtle power. I was impressed for the first time by Kirby Heyborn who irritated me to no end with his overplayed role in the recent The Best Two Years. With this performance it's clear that he has a future as an actor.

Director Ryan Little and writers Geoffrey Panos and Matt Whitaker have done a great job with what little resources they had to work with. This hasn't the budget of a Saving Private Ryan, but Saints and Soldiers does a good job presenting it's themes of faith and honor, and the actors generate real chemistry. With only a few heavy handed moments to speak of (including an unnecessary insert shot toward the end of the picture) I was quite moved by this film.

:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::

al

al

Aluminum foil used in movie to make an angel. However such foil didn't exist until 1947 , some 3 years after this ww2 event.

Adam

Adam

Al,

Wow! And I thought I took movies apart. Interesting observation, but it didn't take away from my overall enjoyment of the film. Hopefully it didn't for you either.

Elder Mast

Elder Mast

I'm happy to see you finally giving an LDS related film a good notice. I realize that you were fair to The Best Two Years, but I think you were a little hard on The RM. As well as Kirby Heybourne - who I consider to be the best actor involved in any of these films.

Richard Meyers

Richard Meyers

"Saints and Soldiers" is a touching and reverent character study involving battle-weary soldiers as they begin to reveal themselves to each other while trapped behind enemy lines.

It would be unfair to compare this film with 100 million dollar films like "Saving Private Ryan," especially since "Saints" was delivered for less than 1 Million - but it's the story that matters and "Saints & Soldiers" is a good one.

Gerald Hawley

Gerald Hawley

Director Ryan Little places the viewer into the action, at times, with a slightly jerky hand-held camera. This compelling cinematography also adds to the film's desolate feel and intensifies the action. More than anything else, "Saint and Solders" is a masterful exapmle of how to simply tell a story and keep the audience interested.

Sharon Gale

Sharon Gale

Within the genre of films by Mormons, about Mormons, "Saints and Soldiers" is easily the best. It is so superior on almost every level, especially in its technical aspects, that it puts hastily assembled drivel like "Handcart" and "The Home Teachers" to even more shame than they were already put to.

Greg Dancer

Greg Dancer

"Saints and Soldiers" represents a significant step forward for LDS filmmaking. Not only is this World War II drama the best locally produced film in quite some time, it may be the first that actually advances the form since the 2000 arrival of "God's Army."

Rachelle Jenkins

Rachelle Jenkins

Definitely the best LDS related film ever made and in truth one of the best war dramas in recent memory. Much better than Tigerland.

Alex Smith

Alex Smith

"Metal foil has been around for centuries. Foil is solid metal that has been reduced to a leaf-like thinness by beating or rolling. The first mass-produced and widely-used foil was made from tin. Tin was later replaced by aluminum in 1910, when the first aluminum foil rolling plant “Dr. Lauber, Neher & Cie., Emmishofen.” was opened in Kreuzlingen, Switzerland.

"The plant, owned by J.G. Neher & Sons (aluminum manufacturers) started in 1886 in Schaffhausen, Switzerland, at the foot of the Rhine Falls - capturing the falls’ energy to produce aluminum. Neher's sons together with Dr. Lauber discovered the endless rolling process and the use of aluminum foil as a protective barrier. From there began the wide use of aluminum foil in the packaging of chocolate bars and tobacco products. Processes evolved over time to include the use of print, color, lacquer, laminate and the embossing of the aluminum."

~ http://inventors.about.com/library/inventors/blaluminum.htm

"At the end of July, 1943, in the tinderbox of a summer heat wave, Bomber Harris ordered his air force to begin a massive air raid on Hamburg, Germany's most important industrial centre and the largest seaport on the European Continent.

"To protect the flyers, Bomber Command had a new technological trick, nicknamed "window." One of the crew would hurl thin strips of aluminum foil out the rear doors of the plane as it flew across German territory. Fluttering in the slipstream, the metal confused the radar that controlled the searchlights and flak guns, sending them swinging erratically across the sky. The Germans would eventually discover the ruse, but not before Hamburg was leveled during a week of devastating raids."

~ http://www.valourandhorror.com/BC/Raids/Firebomb1.htm

Add your own comment here and see it posted immediately!
Name: e-Mail:
Comment:
Spam Prevention Check:
Please enter the following code in the box below.
Security Image