zBoneman.com -- Home

Movie Reviews

The Generals Daughter (1999)

The Generals Daughter
"I don't know how I wound up in this piece of crap--but I'm shooting my way out!"

Starring:

John Travolta
Madeline Stowe

Released By:

Paramount

Released In:

1999

Rated:

R

Reviewed By:

Adam Mast

Grade:

D+

Buy this item at Amazon.com
zBoneman on Rotten Tomatoes

This new military thriller from director Simon West (Con Air) fails on just about every level. Surprisingly, the usually dependable John Travolta is one of the films weak links.

Travolta plays Paul Brenner, an army investigator who is assigned the unpleasant duty of examining the circumstances that surround the death of the general's daughter. To make matters worse, he's partnered with ex-flame and rape-specialist Sarah Sunhill, played by Madeline Stowe in a pointless role, tacked on to add some extra tension that never really surfaced.

The General's Daughter is a half-baked mystery that's pretty easy to solve. It's also quite ugly for a summer film and takes many disheartening and unrealistic pot-shots at the military. As in last years A Civil Action, Travolta seems all wrong for this film. He tries to be a hero like Harrison Ford's in the Tom Clancy films, but can't seem to transcend the material he's working from.

However, the film does get a minimal boost from spectacular performances from James Cromwell as the General, Clarence Williams III as his Chief of Staff, and the always great James Woods as the main suspect in the case--but it doesnÕt add up to much. It's almost as if director Simon West didn't want to be reduced to making Bruckheimer action films, so he tried to make a character study. Ironically, Con Air, in all its gratuitous glory, had more character.

I'm all for dark subject matter--Seven, The Silence of the Lambs, and Kalifornia are all terrific films. This film is just dark and brooding in a way that doesn't draw the audience in.

:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::

Shelley

Shelley

I totally disagree with above Grade. I loved John Travolta and loved the movie. However, at the end of the movie it has a caption stating the General was charged etc. Left one to beliebve it was based on a true story? Is this true?

Anonymous Coward

Anonymous Coward

Is it? It is 2008 and no one has answered!

Janet

Janet

I LOVED this movie it was a comfort film to me, I Was surprised to find out after wattching this film over and over for years that it wasn't true In a way I was glad it wasn't.Thank got the critics arn't always right.

Add your own comment here and see it posted immediately!
Name: e-Mail:
Comment:
Spam Prevention Check:
Please enter the following code in the box below.
Security Image