zBoneman.com -- Home Music Reviews

"eMOTIVe" by A Perfect Circle (2004)

"eMOTIVe" by A Perfect Circle

Artist:

A Perfect Circle

Album:

eMOTIVe

Released In:

2004

Reviewed By:

Kyle England

Grade:

2.0

Buy this item at Amazon.com
zBoneman on Rotten Tomatoes

If Tool fans would like to take there respective shots at me, now's your chance. Let me explain. Last year I was so taken aback by A Perfect Circle's Thirteenth Step album, that I hastily ssuggested that A Perfect Circle should now be Maynard James Keenan's first priority. Well, I got my wish, and what I've received is something that makes we want to go purge my foolish remark by listening to old Tool records.

Released on election day 2004, eMOTIVe is an all cover songs (except for two) album that is based upon the theme of peace love and understanding. That's fine by me; Maynard has shown in the past with Tool (Led Zeppelin's "No Quarter") A Perfect Circle (Failure's "The Nurse Who Loved Me") and even The Replicants (Wings' "Silly Love Songs") that he's capable of taking other artists material and spinning it into gold. The aforementioned covers take the originals and reinvints them in a way that respects the artists who wrote them while elevating them to a higher plane. But eMOTIVe is something completely different - something that I never thought Maynard was capable of: lazy, boring, tedious and artless work. These are only just a few ways to describe this colossal blunder.

Let's get the lesser examples of mediocrity out of the way first, before I rip this album a new asshole. One of the originals here, "Passive," is excellent. It would have accompanied Thirteenth Step very well, if by chance it actually was a track that was left on the cutting room floor from that album. The only two cover songs that work well here are a respectable cover of Devo's "Freedom Of Choice" and a haunting a cappella version of Joni Mitchell's "Fiddle And The Drum" -but that's it. Everything else here is a joke and a complete waste of time.

Versions of Black Flag's "Gimmie Gimmie Gimmie," Depeche Mode's "People Are People" and Fear's "Let's Have A War," are just plain embarrassing, to say the least. If you don't laugh at these covers halfway through them or skip right over them to begin with, there's something very wrong with you. Versions of John Lennon's "Imagine," Marvin Gaye's "What's Going On" and Elvis Costello's "Peace Love And Understanding" are mundane and dull at best. When I was at Lollapolooza last year, Chris Cornell and Maynard did a rousing version of "Peace Love And Understanding" on acoustic guitars that was very powerful. This new re-imagining is just a gothic, industrial, drawn-out mess.

It's very sad indeed to watch a great band like this drag prevalent political songs of the past through the mud and fuck them up this badly. For an album so obsessed with delivering a message of peace, how ironic it is that it's turned out to be such a gigantic bomb.

:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::

runt boy

runt boy

word kyle. exactly what i thought. The album has a very distinct shit smell from being pulled out of Maynard's ass. The depeche mode cover could easily be cool if it wasn't for the chorus cry. this is one of the most anticipated shitty albums of the year.

Tyson's Take

Tyson's Take

For a while I worked in Corona, California building a couple houses.

Every week my boss drove my fellow co-workers and me down to experience

California's over rated treasures. Since A Perfect Circle is one of my

boss's most favorite bands I figure that over the course of driving back

and forth from California for six months I have probably heard APC's

first two albums 2,000 times. I wouldn't really consider myself a fan but

I do however consider myself a knowledgeable person of their music. With

that said I actually tried really hard to like this album but I just

couldn't. It was like I was trying to get turned on by a manikin's nubby

mound- I felt dirty, perverted, and like I needed to take a shower and

ram a pencil into my ear. The recording quality is great. It sounds like

Maynard backed up to the microphone and sprayed diarrhea all over

everything while recording it. All my friends feel the same- it's a real

let down album. Since when has Maynard cared so much about politics? I

wish he would just paint a red and black racing stripe on his naked body

and run around dusted out of his mind like the good old days of Tool.

I hit the streets with my notepad in hand to ask regular consumers their

thoughts on this horrendously bad mistake. Here is what I heard. "Who the

hell is A Perfect Circle?" "Liberal pussies!" and "Tool rocks

bro!"Â…Shocking.

When a cover of Depeche Mode's "people are people" came on I took a double

take at the radio and buried my head in my hands and sobbed; class A shit.

I swear whenever the cover of John Lennon's "Imagine" comes on at work I

just want to put my nail gun up to my head and pull the trigger half a

dozen times. The band covers these songs along with many others,

destroying them in the process. They even manage to massacre their own

songs with retarded remixes.

If the producers would've released it after ODB died I'm sure the album

would've been dedicated to Ol' Dirty and Maynard would've covered Wu

Tang's "Shame on a nigga" to show his love. Well shame on you Maynard,

this like I said before, class A shit..

Chris

Chris

Wow, I have to agree with the review. There are maybe two songs on this CD that I like. I just bought it yesterday and I have never been more disappointed with a CD (I feel like I burned that 15 bucks). I didn't like Imagine after hearing it on the radio, but I said to myself, "How bad could the CD be?" Let's just say that sometimes very soon (probably tomorrow) I am going to go pawn this CD hoping to get an even trade for a different CD at the local pawn shop.

The CD is garbage. I mean if I wanted a piece of shit I could produce that myself, but instead I paid 15 bucks for it. I WAS a fan of A Perfect Circle until I heard this crap. There is maybe one song on the CD that actually uses an electric guitar in overdrive, that alone would've been enough to scare me away had I known.

Fans of previous Tool/Perfect Circle albums would be wise to stay clear of this crappy CD. Just remember that this is coming from someone who owns every Tool CD and was a Huge fan of Mer De Noms. I even paid to see them in concert, but I don't know if Maynard deserves anymore of my money with this garbage. I'll admit that the next time Tool releases an album I'm going to pirate every song first. I'm too afraid that I'll be wasting my money.

It's really sad that I'll have to pirate a CD first to make sure it's any good, but I seriously have never been more disappointed with am album in my life!!!

Add your own comment here and see it posted immediately!
Name: e-Mail:
Comment:
Spam Prevention Check:
Please enter the following code in the box below.
Security Image