zBoneman.com -- Home Music Reviews

"You Could Have It So Much Better" by Franz Ferdinand (2005)

"You Could Have It So Much Better" by Franz Ferdinand

Artist:

Franz Ferdinand

Album:

You Could Have It So Much Better

Released In:

2005

Reviewed By:

Kyle England

Grade:

3.5

Buy this item at Amazon.com
zBoneman on Rotten Tomatoes

With the smash single "Take Me Out" still fresh in the minds of Top 40 fanatics and uber trendy hipsters alike, overnight Scottish superstars Franz Ferdinand follow up their massively successful self-titled debut with the quick sophomore release You Could Have It So Much Better. Not straying too far from the formula that started the goose to laying golden eggs, So Much Better at times almost feels like a carbon copy of last year's blueprint of whip-smart dance punk. However, any time you try to duplicate something the copy always comes off a bit spotty and faded - which is certainly the case with this labored-feeling duplication.. In fact much of You Could Have smacks of major label pressure, to strike while the iron is hot and churn out some more of that radio-friendly magic. Look no further than snoozers like "This Boy" or "Evil And A Heathen" to see exactly what I mean.

You Could Have It So Much Better is actually best when Alex Kapranos and company tone down the razor sharp guitars, taking cues from mellower influences like Orange Juice on "Walking Away" and The Beatles on the double headed beast of "Fade Together" and "Eleanor Put Your Boots On" respectively. (could that Eleanor be Alex's former flame Eleanor Friedberger of The Fiery Furnaces? Inquiring minds want to know!) Even though the previously mentioned toned downed tracks are the better part of So Much Better, there are still a few dance punky numbers that are sheer ear candy. First single "Do You Want To" is a treat with its tongue in cheek homoerotic tendencies. And sure to be second single and album opener "The Fallen" is the barn burner of the bunch with its la la la's and whoo hoo's firmly in place. "I'm Your Villain" with its cocksure marching beat and mid-song tempo change should also end up becoming a fan favorite. But even with the few things that excel on this album, it's too bad it all comes off sounding so forced and rushed - though it's not a fall-on-your-face disaster by any means, you can't help but recognize that we could have had it so much better..

:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::

Mark Larsen

Mark Larsen

Fully agree - in fact I think you give it more credit than it deserves - Bollocks

Josh Haslum

Josh Haslum

Actually under the circumstances I think they managed to make a fairly respectable album.

Jes

Jes

I feel like this album managed to sidestep the sophomore slump (not by much) and there are parts of it that I like even better than their debut. In any case a respectable showing, that points to an actual career, no?

Jeff Hubbard

Jeff Hubbard

Hate to disagree, but disagree I do. I think this record is a lot more fleshed out, in terms of writing, than their debut. And, as grabby singles go, I'll take "Do You Want To" over "Take Me Out" any day of the week. You're absolutely right that their range is in question, and, quite frankly, as a non-disciple, I've suspected that since my first listen to their debut. Interestingly, I'd probably give the album about the same rating that you did, though; maybe a four, tops. Your review comes off as lot more negative than the rating would indicate. Albums described as "forced and rushed" or "labored-feeling" don't usually end up awarded three and a half stars, in my reading experience.

sham-pain

sham-pain

They could have done so much better should be the name of this weak ass record. I wouldn't even call it a sophomore slump because it's such a total carbon copy of their first album. Their first single sounds like every song they've ever recorded.

Add your own comment here and see it posted immediately!
Name: e-Mail:
Comment:
Spam Prevention Check:
Please enter the following code in the box below.
Security Image