zBoneman.com -- Home

Music Reviews

"12 Songs" by Neil Diamond (2005)

"12 Songs" by Neil Diamond

Artist:

Neil Diamond

Album:

12 Songs

Released In:

2005

Reviewed By:

Kyle England

Grade:

3.0

Buy this item at Amazon.com
zBoneman on Rotten Tomatoes

Ah, Neil Diamond. The Jewish Elvis. The master of sequined suits, Hot August Nights, and hairy chested machismo. Anybody out there remember a time when Neil Diamond wasn't a corny, self-righteous, schmaltz master? Did you know he actually used to play a guitar AND write all his own somewhat rockin' songs? I know it's hard to believe that a man beloved by housewives and grandmothers across this nation actually wrote songs like "Cracklin' Rosie," "Kentucky Woman," and even "I'm A Believer," (for The Monkees of course) but go with me on this one, he really used to.

Well, super producer Rick Rubin for Beastie Boys, Slayer, Red Hot Chili Peppers and Johnny Cash's four American Recordings albums remembers, and can you believe he's a fan? He actually sought Diamond out personally, and after months of lobbying, convinced Diamond to agree to a return to yesteryear - 30 yesteryears give or take. Diamond finally acquiesced and for his part Neil agreed to write all of his own songs and play guitar like back in the day. Naturally since Rubin pulled this off, not to mention coaxing all those amazing records out of Johnny Cash - 12 Songs has to be that long awaited masterpiece, right? Well . . .

The album opens with a song called "Oh Mary," an acoustic tune that sounds like a winner, but ends up being a pretty cheesy piece of work. And then comes "Hell Yeah," an even more pungent hunk of cheese. "Oy vey." Then comes "Captain Of A Shipwreck" and I'm about ready to eject this thing before it leaves a permanent smell in my car. Happily after such a rocky start, Diamond actually starts to pull out some very strong and sincere material - some of his best in nearly 30 years.

"Evermore" is a beautiful string-laden work that starts off acoustic, but by the end is big and robust, (but not in that over-bloated - "someone please kill me now" kind of way). He actually pulls off the big anthem without me wanting to stick fingers in my ears. "Save Me A Saturday Night" and "Delirious Love" are excellent songs that are very reminiscent of some of his earliest work. But the two gems Diamond should be the most proud of are "I'm On To You," a slinky little number in the same vein as "Girl, You'll Be A Woman Soon," and the album closer "We," a sweet little number that would have been perfect for Harry Nilsson back in his heyday. 12 songs isn't perfect, far from it in fact, but I can honestly say this is the most enjoyable album that Diamond has released in over 20 years, and that's just enough to make a new believer out of me.

:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::

Jeff Hubbard

Jeff Hubbard

This is one helluva massively over-hyped record. What we have here is just some sort of collective wishful thinking on the part of critics (though the "why" is a bit baffling; I almost believe that it's more that critics want to see Rick Rubin's winning streak continue, rather than a desire to see Diamond redeemed. He's never been much of a critics darling.) Hey, like most people, I truly enjoy about 10 or 15 tunes from Diamond's '60's and very early '70's peak, but since that ended over 30 years ago, I didn't exactly hope for genius at this late date. So I wasn't disappointed; the album is ultimately maudlin and underwhelming melodically. During the run of the record, I kept thinking to myself, "Self, if Diamond is going to make a determined effort to create brooding, downcast music, couldn't he at least write ONE damn tune that approaches the occasionally silly yet undeniably moving "I Am, I Said." Nope. Not a chance. "Evermore" is pretty good, though, and there are, as Kyle indicates, one or two other keepers. I guess my negativity stems directly from the widespread notion that this album represents some kind of career apothesis for ol' Neil, and it just ain't so, folks. Proceed with caution.

Billy Culp

Billy Culp

Personally I think Neil Diamond has always been pretty cool. One of the first albums I ever owned was his Tap Root Manuscript. Not his best known album but it has this great song that's almost like early rap: Jesus Christ Fanny Brice Lenny Brice and on to H G Wells, Humphrey Bogart and Wolfgang Mozart and so forth - it was pretty radical for it's time especially for Neil. The fact is he's written at least 2 Dozen top drawer songs and he's still kicking - you have to respect that.

Debbie Davis

Debbie Davis

I think you were going a little hard on Neil, I've always thought of him as being quite a talent both as a singer and a song writer. And I dare say I liked all 12 of these songs. Great Album

Donna

Donna

I like 12 Songs quite abit, being a fan for the last nearly 39 years--so I am telling my age, but Neil has always been Neil, and if someone wants to bellyache about his new album, that's their right, but I for one, not just like it, I love it even more when someone else takes the time to ditch it! Go Neil, KEEP ON ROCKING!!!!

Add your own comment here and see it posted immediately!
Name: e-Mail:
Comment:
Spam Prevention Check:
Please enter the following code in the box below.
Security Image