zBoneman.com -- Home Music Reviews

"Prairie Wind" by Neil Young (2005)

"Prairie Wind" by Neil Young

Artist:

Neil Young

Album:

Prairie Wind

Released In:

2005

Reviewed By:

Kyle England

Grade:

3.0

Buy this item at Amazon.com
zBoneman on Rotten Tomatoes

Prairie Wind, if you can believe it or not, is Neil Young's 30th studio record to date, and is his first album since his nearly fatal brain aneurysm last year. It's also his first album since his father's passing, and you don't have to be a rocket scientist to hear that's primarily what's on his mind. Bound in country roots like previous releases such as Harvest, Comes a Time and Silver & Gold, Prairie Wind is an album that looks to the past fondly, and certainly feels like a tribute to Older Youngs. On the excellent "Falling Off The Face Of The Earth," Young sings in a broken heartfelt voice "I just want to tell you, you sure mean a lot to me. It may sound simple, but you are the world to me." And on "Far From Home," thoughts of dad are definitely at the forefront with the opening lines "When I was a growing boy rockin' on my daddy's knee, daddy took an old guitar and sang 'bury me on the lone prairie'".

Even with all the country inflections and being recorded in Nashville, Prairie Wind has to be the least country sounding of Young's so-called country records. Young and producer Ben Keith might as well have recorded this album at Muscle Shoals with all the horn arrangements that are scattered about here. And to be honest, the horns hinder, not help most of the songs. Also, the string arrangements on the overly long "It's a Dream" are overbearing to say the least. Overly long is actually the perfect way to describe half the songs here. Instead of being tightly knit, most of Prairie Wind, especially the self-titled track, feels drawn out and half-baked. But as far as sincerity goes, this is Young at his most personal; and I'll take an album like this over previous recent messy disasters like Are You Passionate? and Greendale any day of the week.

:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::

Janice Whiting

Janice Whiting

Seems to me like your kind of knitpicking and being a little overcritical - people tend to lose their bearings under times of great stress, perhaps those drawn out lapses of strings are truly the beauty of the mans tribute, who're you to say?

Mike Rose

Mike Rose

More boring crap as fara as I'm concerned, Neil seems to have lost the importance or including melodies with his words.I don't mean to sound so disrespectful, especially in light of his life. But it's been so long since h'e hit pay dirt that I'm getting discouraged. The man is one of the great tunesmith's of all time - all I want is a tune?

Add your own comment here and see it posted immediately!
Name: e-Mail:
Comment:
Spam Prevention Check:
Please enter the following code in the box below.
Security Image