zBoneman.com -- Home

Music Reviews

"III" by Van Halen (1998)

"III" by Van Halen

Artist:

Van Halen

Album:

III

Released In:

1998

Reviewed By:

Ryan Slack

Grade:

3.5

Buy this item at Amazon.com
zBoneman on Rotten Tomatoes

The long overdue and highly anticipated Van Halen III is finally here--and along with it is the big question --will the material hold up to the hype? Reassembled with ex-Extreme lead singer Gary Cherone, Van Halen now bears the beastly burden of proof--can they possibly make a third incarnation work?

Change is relevant with newcomer Cherone, who lends a subtle, serene sense of security to this record. It comes off well, but his vocals are, at times, too similar to VH's previous mouthpiece, Sammy Hagar. Some may not even notice Sammy's absence. Whether long-time fans will accept Cherone or not is questionable. He is, however, straight-forward and rather compelling, and seems to fit right in.

Cherone wrote most of the lyrics for this album and drives powerful meaning to the music. While Eddie's spiritual awakening and emotional maturity have possibly resulted in his best work to date. The 43 year old guitar legend has lifted his fretwork into new dimensions with a stripped-down examination that constantly bends, pushes and pulls you to the edge. In addition to his phenomenal guitar stylings, Eddie took part in co-producing this record, and even sings lead vocals, while accompanying himself on piano on the impressive ballad "How Many Say I." This honest look at interdependency, is a valiant effort for Eddie--moving and lyrically inspiring.

While the single, "Without You" holds strong, in no way does it prepare you from what lies hidden within VH III. The energy constantly flows with remarkable tracks such as, "From Afar," "Year To The Day," and the epic "Once." VH III proves beyond a doubt that Eddie can still make the band Jump . . . Right Now.

:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::

bobby singer

bobby singer

The first thing that needs to be said is that this album is nowhere near as bad as some of the reviews I've seen for it. Also important to mention is that Gary Cherone sounds VERY similar to Sammy Hagar (whom he replaced). It's not as commercial as their previous work with Hagar and I'm guessing that is why most Hagar fans don't like it. In terms of Roth era VH fans I would suspect that many of them didn't like the Hagar era so they probably weren't too crazy about this incarnation either. The album itself is uneven I'll admit. "Without You" is a strong opener with some stong reminders that Cherone was the singer for Extreme. "One I Want" is the best song on this collection lyrically and musically and finds the band taking chances they had long abandoned with Hagar. "Fire In The Hole" is a straight ahead rocker that covers familiar ground but is good nonetheless. Aside from these 3 songs the album is uneven. "From Afar" will be a welcome change to some but to others it might be considered rock n roll blasphemy. Eddie VH's attempt at lead vocals also will miss the mark with many I'm sure. Overall I thought this album was decent. Van Halen took chances musically which is something they hadn't done since David Lee Roth was at the helm. The results however were mixed. Still it's an interesting listen and got them out of the top 40/AOR radio friendly to a fault rut they had been in since Roth left. I would give it a 6 on a scale of 1 to 10.

Add your own comment here and see it posted immediately!
Name: e-Mail:
Comment:
Spam Prevention Check:
Please enter the following code in the box below.
Security Image